Should Taxotere Plaintiffs be Concerned After First Bellwether Trial? Absolutely Not.

Taxotere Trial Defense Strategy

“The Devil Did It”

A jury in Louisiana federal court handed the defendant a victory in the first Taxotere Bellwether presided over by U.S. District Judge Jane Triche Milazzo in New Orleans. The case, filed in December 2016 by Louisiana resident Barbara Earnest, had been designated as a Bellwether in a multidistrict litigation consolidated before Judge Milazzo.

http://www.laed.uscourts.gov/case-information/mdl-mass-class-action/taxotere

https://www.reuters.com/article/products-liability-taxotere/sanofi-wins-first-bellwether-trial-in-taxotere-litigation-idUSL2N26I1P6

Should other Taxotere Plaintiffs be concerned about this initial trial loss? Not really, and we will explain why.
Barbara Earnest’s case was unusual in that she required more than one round of chemotherapy to treat her cancer. She received a round of Taxotere and round of Doxorubicin.

Doxorubicin is a cytotoxic chemotherapy drug and an antitumor antibiotic; it deservedly has been nicknamed the Red Devil. Doxorubicin is a bright, almost florescent, red color.

Despite Doxorubicin not being associated with significant incidents of permanent hair loss, unlike Taxotere, defense counsel took full advantage of the Doxorubicin nick name “Red Devil” and was able to persuade the jury that it was not Taxotere that caused Barbara Earnest permanent hair loss, it was the Devil that did it.

The next Taxotere case up for trial does not involve a dual Taxotere followed by Doxorubicin or vice versa, circumstance. Defense counsel will not be able to claim the devil did it, in the next case.

So, in answer to the question, “Should other Taxotere Plaintiffs be concerned about this initial trial loss?” the answer is no. There are more trials to come and the “facts” of the first case tried are, by no means, the same as those in the majority of other Taxotere plaintiffs’ cases.

If making reference to Bayer’s past connection to Nazis is so inflammatory and prejudicial to be uttered before a jury, where Bayer is a defendant, one would think that using the term “Red Devil” to describe Doxorubicin, the drug’s actual name, in the Barbara Earnest case should equally qualify as too inflammatory and prejudicial for the jury to hear. Plaintiffs counsel objected to the use of “Red Devil”; however, Judge Milazzo nonetheless allowed the Louisiana jury to be led to believe that the Devil had worked some Voodoo, and that was the actual cause of Barbara Earnest’s permanent disfigurement, vs the drug Taxotere, that has actually been shown to cause the type of injuries suffered by Barbara Earnest.

If Judge Milazzo presides over another Taxotere trial in which Doxorubicin was also administered, the Honorable Judge may consider making the defendant refer to the drug by its proper name rather than leading a jury to believe the devil did the deed.

In light of the recent $8 Billion dollar verdict in a Risperdal trial, and multiple other recent Billion Dollar verdicts in mass litigation cases, Sanofi, the maker of Taxotere, may want to think twice about how many times it rolls the dice with a jury trial. If they can’t blame the devil in other cases, they may find that one or more juries find them liable and award more to a single plaintiff that it would take to settle the entire litigation, disposing of all plaintiffs’ cases.

Read the ALM Taxotere Defense Verdict

Learn the Business of Mass Torts, How to Avoid Getting Screwed in an MDL, the Behind-the-Curtain Information on Taxotere, Truvada, Hernia Mesh, and Other Emerging and Current Litigations… Register Today for the Only Mass Tort Immersion Course.

The Mass Tort Nexus Four Days to Mass Tort Success Course gives you the knowledge, information and skills that current “mass tort insiders” learned the hard way (trial and error). It is better to learn from the mistakes of others than to make those same mistakes yourself.

If you are interested in working smarter versus harder, and achieving the financial goals you have set for yourself and your firm, the Four Days to Mass Tort Success Course is the place to start. Click on the image below to register for the November course. You may also call or email Barbara Capasso or Anne-Marie Kopek at 954-530-9892, email barbara@masstortnexus.com or annemarie@masstortnexus.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *