New Jersey State Court MCL Designations: Is NJ the emerging state court mass tort venue for lawsuits against Big Pharma?
By Mark A. York (May 11, 2018)
(Mass Tort Nexus Media) In late 2017 plaintiffs and defendants in the Abilify litigation in New Jersey state court moved to have the litigation designated as a multicounty litigation (MCL) on December 27, 2017 and which was approved as an MCL on May 9, 2018, see links below for both court filings.
The New Jersey judiciary site provides multicounty litigation docket information where you will see there are more MCL dockets that parallel existing federal MDL’s being brought in Big Pharma’s backyard. These multicounty litigations involve large numbers of claims that are associated with pharmaceuticals and medical devices based in New Jersey, and there appears to be an emerging consensus that confronting J&J, Sanofi and others in their home state venue is now a very viable litigation option for mass tort firms across the country. The recently consolidated Abilify MCL is a prime example, as is the pending Taxotere MCL application.
There were nearly 50 Abilify cases filed in Bergen County in New Jersey Superior Court, with that number expected to rise over the next few months, with Superior Court Judge James DeLuca having been the initial judge handling the docket, both plaintiff and defense had agreed that the cases should remain with Judge DeLuca. However, the May 7, 2018 order designated Superior court Judge Nelson C. Johnson and the Atlantic county court as the Abilify New Jersey MCL venue, Abilify New Jersey MCL Designation Atlantic County May 7, 2018.
The motion for MCL designation was filed to ensure that any Abilify case filed in New Jersey will be transferred into the designated state court venue and remain there. There is already a multidistrict litigation (MDL) designation in the Abilify federal litigation, which is consolidated in Northern District of Florida, where the three upcoming bellwether trial were just settled, as well as pending “global settlement order, see Abilify MDL 2734 Global Settlement Order, where Judge Casey Rodgers ordered the parties to reach an agreement within 120 days of the May 1, 2018 order entry date. The MDL for Abilify was consolidated in October 2016, before U.S. District Judge M. Casey Rodgers.
NEW JERSEY STATE COURT ETHICON MESH CONSOLIDATION
Ethicon now faces a home state hernia mesh legal battle as the New Jersey Supreme Court posted the Application for Multicounty Litigation (MCL) status on April 11, 2018 regarding the emerging Ethicon/J&J multi-layered hernia mesh products litigation pending in New Jersey state courts, Ethicon Hernia Mesh Litigation MCL Notice – New Jersey State Court April 11, 2018. The filing requests the Ethicon hernia mesh cases be consolidated in Bergen County in front of Judge Rachell Harz, over litigation related to Ethicon’s Proceed, Physiomesh and Prolene synthetic hernia mesh products. For information regarding the New Jersey Ethicon Hernia Mesh Litigation see Mass Tort Nexus Briefcase Re: Ethicon Hernia Mesh New Jersey State Court Consolidation, adding another docket of mesh cases to the ever growing J&J/Ethicon defense of its synthetic surgical mesh products.
As a growing number of hernia mesh lawsuits continue to be filed against Johnson & Johnson and it’s Ethicon subsidiary in New Jersey state court, each involving complications allegedly caused by the design of multi-layered patch products sold in recent years, a request has been filed to centralize the litigation before one judge for coordinated pretrial proceedings.
On April 11, Glenn A. Grant, acting administrative director of New Jersey state courts, issued a Notice To The Bar (PDF), indicating that the state Supreme Court has received an application to create a multicounty litigation (MCL) for all product liability lawsuits over Ethicon multi-layered hernia mesh.
TAXOTERE EMERGING MCL
The most recent MCL application to be filed and listed by the New Jersey Courts is the Taxotere (docetaxel) cancer chemotherapy drug litigation against Sanofi-Aventis US, Sandoz, Inc. and Actavis, Inc with the MCL Notice posted on April 11, 2018 see Taxotere New Jersey MCL Notice To The Bar April 11, 2018.
There is already an existing Taxotere MDL 2740 in the US District Court ED Louisiana see Mass Tort Nexus Briefcase TAXOTERE-MDL-2740-(US-District-Court-Eastern-District-of-Louisiana, where there are more than 5,000 claims pending in front of the very soon to depart Chief Judge Kurt D. Englehardt, who recently received full US Senate approval to move up to the Forth Circuit Court of Appeals, replaced by sitting US District Court Judge, Jane Triche Milazzo.
How the New Jersey state court Taxotere MCL compares to the Taxotere MDL 2740 remains to be seen, but the New Jersey based pharmaceutical giants are now being forced to address mass torts more and more often in their home state courts, which previously was perceived as a venue of last resort for many plaintiff firms across the country.
With these three newest mass torts emerging in New Jersey state courts, along with the many pre-existing MCL’s that have been very successful there, will New Jersey now be considered the “go to” venue for filing litigation against Big PharMa?